In the ongoing battle against fraud, businesses have long been viewed as less vulnerable than individuals. Historically, the narrative has focused on consumers as the primary targets for fraudsters, with businesses often seen as stable entities capable of defending themselves. However, this perception is rapidly changing. The focus of fraudulent activities is shifting, and small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) are increasingly in the crosshairs. This evolution in fraud patterns demands a reevaluation of how financial institutions (FIs) approach fraud detection and prevention, particularly as the tactics used against businesses become more sophisticated and targeted.
The Shift from Consumer to SMB Fraud
Businesses don't commit fraud—people do. This distinction has always been clear. However, the methods by which fraudsters exploit businesses, especially SMBs, are becoming alarmingly creative. Fraudsters are now applying the tactics traditionally used in consumer identity theft to the business world, particularly targeting established SMBs with solid reputations and histories. This migration from consumer to SMB fraud highlights a critical vulnerability: the assumption that established businesses are inherently safe from fraud.
One of the most notable shifts is the rise in business identity theft. Just as fraudsters have stolen personal identities to open credit accounts or take out loans, they are now stealing the identities of established businesses. The theory is simple yet effective: a business with a long history and verifiable credentials (such as a known address, phone number, and email) raises fewer red flags during the onboarding process. By impersonating these businesses, fraudsters can more easily gain access to financial services, open fraudulent accounts, and conduct illicit activities with less scrutiny.
Patterns in SMB Fraud: New Tactics, Old Techniques
Two emerging patterns illustrate how fraudsters are exploiting SMBs:
- Reactivating Dormant Businesses: Fraudsters are increasingly targeting businesses that have been inactive or dissolved. By reinstating business licenses and filing annual reports, they can make these companies appear active and in good standing. This tactic is particularly effective in states like Florida, where the process to form a business is both cheap and quick. Once the business is reinstated, the fraudster can use it as a vehicle for further fraudulent activities, leveraging the business's established reputation to bypass fraud prevention measures.
- Infiltrating Business Leadership: Another related tactic involves fraudsters inserting themselves into a company’s leadership. By filing reports that list themselves as an officer, director, or manager of the company, they can gain control over the business’s financial activities. This manipulation of official records makes it difficult to distinguish legitimate business actions from fraudulent ones, allowing the fraudster to operate under the guise of a legitimate business leader.
These tactics reflect a broader trend: fraudsters are becoming more sophisticated in their approach to exploiting SMBs, using established business credentials to mask their true identities. This evolution underscores the need for financial institutions to put the right tools and processes in place to evaluate businesses with the same level of scrutiny as they do individuals in the onboarding process.
Are SMB-Focused FIs Underprepared?
Many financial institutions that specialize in serving SMBs may find themselves underprepared to prevent this new wave of fraud. Traditionally, the focus has been on consumer fraud prevention, with business fraud considered a secondary concern. However, as fraudsters increasingly target SMBs, FIs must adapt their strategies.
One of the key challenges is the reliance on traditional fraud detection methods that may not be equipped to identify the nuances of SMB fraud. For example, systems that flag inconsistencies in consumer data may not be as effective when applied to businesses, where changes in leadership or business status can be legitimate and routine. However, these same changes can also be signs of fraud, as seen in the tactics described above.
To address these challenges, FIs need to deploy more sophisticated tools that can analyze business entities with the same rigor as individual accounts. This includes integrating compliance and risk insights into their fraud detection frameworks, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of what constitutes suspicious activity in the context of SMBs. By doing so, FIs can better protect themselves and their customers from the growing threat of business-related fraud.
Treating Businesses Like People: A New Approach to Fraud Detection
As fraudsters continue to exploit businesses as vehicles for fraud, it's crucial for FIs to rethink how they treat business entities in their fraud detection efforts. Traditionally, businesses have been viewed as stable, less risky entities compared to individual consumers. However, the growing trend of business identity theft and leadership manipulation shows that this perception is outdated.
FIs must adopt a more holistic approach to fraud detection, one that treats businesses as dynamic entities capable of being manipulated by bad actors. This means applying the same principles used in consumer fraud detection—such as identity verification, behavioral analysis, and risk scoring—to business entities. By doing so, FIs can catch fraudulent activity before it escalates, protecting both their own interests and those of their SMB customers.
Conclusion
The migration of fraud from consumers to SMBs represents a significant shift in the fraud landscape. As fraudsters continue to innovate and adapt, so too must the financial institutions that serve SMBs. By recognizing the vulnerabilities in current fraud detection methods and investing in more sophisticated tools and insights, FIs can stay ahead of the curve and ensure a smoother, more secure onboarding process for their legitimate business customers. The future of fraud prevention lies in treating businesses with the same level of scrutiny as individuals, ensuring that every detail is thoroughly examined in the business onboarding process.
Contact our sales team for a demo today to learn how Middesk can help you identify and prevent high-risk businesses from accessing your platform.
